So I spend A LONG time figuring out why this happened. And I think I figured it out.
I started by deleting elements 1 by 1 and see if it changed anything.
Seems I added one radio button in my popup with a value of “Webflow”. And I changed that value to “Webflow-Expert” and that seems to have fixed the issue. So I guess the value “Webflow” is reserved or something, causing things to break. Super weird.
But good news, I think I finally found the issue. Fingers crossed it keeps working